Why is homeschooling banned in germany

The rare exceptions are for severe illnesses, the children of diplomats, and in rare instances for working children, such as child actors. The KMK said it believes there are between and 1, cases of parents homeschooling their children across Germany. While private schooling exists in Germany , it is far less common than in many other countries; German private schools also broadly follow the curriculum of the state where they're based. German pupils from disadvantaged backgrounds still lag behind their counterparts from affluent families, a new OECD study shows.

But there was some good news as far as social mobility in education is concerned. Visit the new DW website Take a look at the beta version of dw. Go to the new dw. More info OK. Wrong language? Change it here DW. Ultimately, in answer to the question as to whether there is a right to homeschool under international law, the answer is no.

Parents enjoy the freedom to raise their children in line with their religious and moral beliefs, and free from unnecessary state interference. However, children enjoy the right to education. Both are important but parental freedom cannot trump the rights of the child.

And, as we have seen, under international law, it is for the states themselves to determine standards and regulations and, as a consequence, to what degree parents are free to homeschool their children.

Un article faux de bout en bout. Ce qui demeure en droit en est une autre. Children's education is a must. They will make the society of tomorrow. So, we should give them the opportunity to learn better. The article is interesting as example whereby the desired conclusion — the state apparatus has a largely unlimited right to interfere in families and the upbringing of children, nay the state is the primary parent of the child — is embedded in the vocabulary and idioms used to describe the laws imposed by the various governmental apparatuses around the world.

In the end, when you have such an intolerable imposition without recourse to a democratic solution, it comes down to who has the biggest firepower and this is usually the state apparatus. Let us not kid ourselves that it was ever otherwise. Great read!! Thanks for sharing such a great blog, blog like these will surely help each and every homeschooler in homeschooling their children. Yes,of course children have the right to enjoy education in their home. Given that we are caught up in terms of the history of homeschooling see here , there is one notable historical anecdote we have left out: the case of Germany, one of few western European countries with a complete ban on homeschooling.

There is an irritating and pervasive habit to treat the passing of a law elsewhere as an argument in favor of passing it in your own country. The fact that many European countries have stronger regulation and even outright bans on homeschooling is supposed to represent some kind of moral consensus on the matter that should inform American law. This kind of argument is ridiculous even by its own methods, because I can also find several other countries where homeschooling is legal and use it as a cheap argument to keep homeschooling legal worldwide.

Interestingly, homeschooling has resurged most strongly in countries with ties to the British Empire: the U. The countries where homeschooling is illegal or severely restricted include virtually all of eastern Asia, Spain, Germany, much of eastern Europe and half of South America.

First, as we noted in the previous post, modern day Germany may have implemented some of the first public schools in Europe in the s with prominent support from Martin Luther. Nonetheless, homeschooling continued well into the s.

The Nazis outlawed homeschooling upon implementation of the Reichsschulpflichtgesetz Law on Compulsory Education in the German Reich in the very first section, which translates to the following [3]:. Compulsory general education. In the German Reich there is compulsory education. The court disagreed. But it did let the parents retain custody of their four children. But homeschooling is still illegal here. Mike Donnelly is hopeful that things could eventually change and parents might be allowed to homeschool their kids even if it comes with some regulations.

Back to the topic page "Close up ". Deutsch English. Martha Dalton Why is homeschooling illegal in Germany?